Hacker News

Top stories

Live mirror
30 storiesupdated just nowView source snapshot
  1. Laya the open source version of Jev(convaiinnovations.com ↗)
    139comments
  2. A graphical desktop for the ZX Spectrum(github.com/mindbox77 ↗)
    47comments
  3. Tin: full-text search for Postgres(planetscale.com ↗)
    39comments
  4. AI-generated posters don’t have to be horrible(john.hartnup.uk ↗)
    450comments
  5. Human brain is two separate organs, Stanford Medicine-led research finds(stanford.edu ↗)
    180comments
  6. “The Secret Life of Circuits” is here(coredump.cx ↗)
    51comments
  7. Asking Authors About Their Own Papers(medium.com/tmlrorg ↗)
    34comments
  8. Black Holes or Black Hole Stars? Astronomers Spar over 'Little Red Dots'(quantamagazine.org ↗)
    12comments
  9. I built the fastest PHP webserver in the world(qbixserver.com ↗)
    27comments
  10. Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP(grapheneos.social ↗)
    549comments
  11. San Francisco Onion Futures Company(onionfutures.com ↗)
    115comments
  12. GPT-6 Astra Solves a WWI German Radio Cipher(prinzai.com ↗)
    132comments
  13. New evidence for hidden chambers beyond Tutankhamun's tomb(nature.com ↗)
    4comments
  14. If math is more than proof, we need to better celebrate the rest of it(terrytao.wordpress.com ↗)
    189comments
  15. What Zig felt like, coming from Rust(besok.github.io ↗)
    106comments
  16. Cloudflare Quick Tunnels(cloudflare.com ↗)
    301comments
  17. Learning Another Language May Be One of the Best Ways to Keep Your Brain Healthy(theconversation.com ↗)
    39comments
  18. How to Write with an LLM(sockpuppet.org ↗)
    360comments
  19. Agreement between the USA and Denmark (1951,2004) [pdf](state.gov ↗)
    12comments
  20. You can run Git on object storage if you re-make packfiles(tigrisdata.com ↗)
    24comments
  21. Communication by means of modulated Johnson noise(pnas.org ↗)
    18comments
  22. Saving another 100TB of RAM(cloudflare.com ↗)
    89comments
  23. SDCC – Small Device C Compiler(sourceforge.net ↗)
    23comments
  24. Ray Ozzie and the Optimism of Being Early(reproof.app ↗)
    11comments
  25. Science Is Open Software(jepedersen.dk ↗)
    51comments
  26. Why building a Rust LSP is hard(rust-glancer.github.io ↗)
    44comments
  27. Ctenophores: Wonders of Biology(quantamagazine.org ↗)
    7comments
  28. The first new cat species discovered in 100 years(nationalgeographic.com ↗)
    122comments
  29. OpenJev(openjev.com ↗)
    278comments
  30. From Stonemasons to Carpenters(thelastsoftwareengineer.substack.com ↗)
    4comments

Shirky: A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy

57 pointsby 15y agoshirky.com
15 comments
15y agoHN ↗

Thanks for that, the full text is a much better read than Jeff's cut down version.

15y agoHN ↗

Great, informative read. Have to complain about this bit tho:

But learning from experience is the worst possible way to learn something. Learning from experience is one up from remembering. That's not great. The best way to learn something is when someone else figures it out and tells you: "Don't go in that swamp. There are alligators in there."

Works great for avoiding alligators. Fails miserably for riding bikes.

15y agoHN ↗

I dunno about that. I think it's probably easier to learn to ride a bike with someone experienced helping you.

If someone sets up the seat for you and explains how to shift and brake and rides with you a little bit, I'm sure learning would go much faster than if you were just left in a driveway with a bike and told to figure it out.

15y agoHN ↗

Not to detract from your point necessarily, but my anecdotal experience contrasts with this. I had no luck being told how to ride (I guess someone skilled in teaching rather than bike riding may have helped). In the end I was literally left in the driveway with a bike and not allowed back inside until I could ride. I picked it up in an afternoon.

15y agoHN ↗

When learning to ride a bike brakes and shifters are really irrelevant. You're going to crash anyway.

As for how I learned to ride, my dad took me to a hill, sat me on the bike and pushed me down. I learned how to ride pretty quick...well until I hit a small stump hidden by the grass.

After that I was mostly fine and learned to ride pretty quick.

15y agoHN ↗

Indeed.

If you want a kid to learn to ride a bike, remove the fear of failure. Do it on a gently sloping grassy hill that levels out, for example.

When I first learned to ice skate I learned that falling on ice fucking hurts. I didn't learn to ice skate. I learned to not fall over. Then my friend dressed me up in his team's goalie's pads - I pretty much bounced back up again if I fell over. By the end of an hour I could do the sprint exercises with the team and keep up (over short distances anyway!).

15y agoHN ↗

Yeah, I flinched at that part too, but for a different reason: it assumes that everyone else is honest and has the same goals you do.

Hiking destinations. I have a longtime friend and hiking buddy who really likes tough, exposed hikes up to the top of something, with a perverse derision towards anything resembling a freshwater source anywhere along the hike. But he also can't stand mosquitoes. At all. So, he might say, "Don't go in that meadow, there are mosquitoes in there." For me, they're annoying, but I like little hidden meadows, so maybe I want to go there.

And, also, there's a chance that you'll figure out something that nobody else has. You go in that swamp, even though someone warned you about the alligators, and you manage to avoid the alligators but you get a cut while you're in there and you discover that the swamp muck does something interesting with cuts, it actually disinfects them and helps them heal better.

My dad used to say that a smart man learns from his mistakes and a wise man learns from others'. The older I get, the more skeptical I become about that.

15y agoHN ↗

More likely, some exotic bacteria gets in the cut and you develop necrotizing fascitis.

Learning from your own mistakes instead of others' is a high-variance strategy. Our culture is better off because of the people that do it, but if you're selfishly looking to maximize your own expected value, you'll put great weight on the majoritarian view.

15y agoHN ↗

I am often grateful that humans are not perfect game theory machines.

15y agoHN ↗

It would certainly be depressing to live in a world of John Nashes. On the other hand, if everyone were perfect bounded rationalists, we'd merely have to replace Causal Decision Theory and Evidential Decision Theory with something that can solve coordination problems--probably a variant of Timeless Decision Theory, which could already solve this particular problem in many ways.

15y agoHN ↗

LambdaMOO is a fascinating virtual world. Users are allowed to expand the virtual world by building areas, and users with the Programmer Bit are also allowed to program new objects and areas.

15y agoHN ↗

Is there any MUD/MUSH/MOO where this doesn't happen? SMAUG allows you to do that as well.

15y agoHN ↗

A recklessness on the part of the author within an otherwise thought-provoking set of ideas: his analogy concerning Calvinism and the "Book of Revelations" limps badly for a strawman. Evidently, not much time was spent reading John Calvin's "Brève Instruction chrétienne" (Brief Outline of the Christian Faith) nor "Revelation" (singular).

15y agoHN ↗

Yes, it's a good read, but it's eight years old (not that old is bad, just that it's not "news") and this essay has appeared in many places over the years, including the book "Best of Software Writing I", edited by Joel Spolsky.