Hacker News

Top stories

Live mirror
30 storiesupdated just nowView source snapshot
  1. GPT-6 Sol and Luna(openai.com)
    503comments
  2. Claude Opus 5.5(anthropic.com)
    720comments
  3. Microsoft killed FoxPro in 2007. Anyway, here's FoxPro revived(foxscript.org)
    46comments
  4. OpenAI GPT–6 Astra breaks Enigma message that has resisted solution since 2005(cryptocellar.org)
    346comments
  5. 'We hacked the FBI:' Hackers say they have data on all FBI employees(404media.co)
    154comments
  6. The UV index is not the warm sensation of sunlight on bare skin(asciitweezers.com)
    18comments
  7. SAML: A Fractal of Bad Design(trailofbits.com)
    49comments
  8. Claude Opus 5.5 Intelligence, Performance and Price Analysis (Max)(artificialanalysis.ai)
    53comments
  9. WordPress: Unauthenticated path traversal leading to conditional RCE(github.com/wordpress)
    66comments
  10. Unreal Agent(unreallabs.ai)
    54comments
  11. Native apps written in TypeScript and CSS(github.com/geastack)
    10comments
  12. What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals(kqed.org)
    53comments
  13. An update on how we confirm your age group on Discord(discord.com)
    25comments
  14. Markdown in /src(htmx.org)
    24comments
  15. Show HN: JevBench, a reproducible benchmark for typed decision models(benchmarkheaven.com)
    5comments
  16. How did AMD Ryzen get 50% faster in two years?(lemire.me)
    36comments
  17. MUNI Heritage Weekend in San Francisco(lawrence.lu)
    33comments
  18. Did OpenAI solve the wrong Navier-Stokes problem?(scientificamerican.com)
    33comments
  19. OpenAI is well positioned to fast-follow Jev(arcturus-labs.com)
    177comments
  20. The trouble with 'ntile()'(djnavarro.net)
    discuss
  21. Show HN: Training a model to identify AI web content from structure alone(arxiv.org)
    8comments
  22. George Lucas Returns to Earth, Bearing Gifts(commonedge.org)
    27comments
  23. Rabbit Hole: Minimum L-seams(fractalkitty.com)
    5comments
  24. Pentagon says overreliance on AI contributed to missile strike on Iran school(bloomberg.com)
    145comments
  25. 16-bit Intel 8088 chip (c. 1985)(allpoetry.com)
    13comments
  26. People hooked on vapes try a new way to quit: cigarettes(bloomberg.com)
    53comments
  27. Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy(techradar.com)
    416comments
  28. There's a high chance of devices being sold with GrapheneOS preinstalled in 2027(grapheneos.social)
    103comments
  29. Launch HN: Coverage Cat (YC S22) – Umbrella insurance via your personal agent(coveragecat.com)
    19comments
  30. The JavaScript Midlife Crisis(maroun-baydoun.com)
    6comments

Oil and gas prices jump after Iran and Israel attack gasfields

107 pointsby 6mo agotheguardian.com
70 comments
6mo agoHN ↗

Some airlines are cancelling flights left and right, others are jacking up the prices. If the war keeps going on into the summer, there's going to be some very obvious consumer-facing issues. From gas prices, very expensive travel, price hikes in logistics, you name it.

6mo agoHN ↗

I think the timeline is much shorter than that. These oil-producing nations have not invested in a lot of storage, because they usually ship everything out immediately. Once you no longer have anywhere to put the oil, you have to start shutting down production, and it is not easy to restart. We'll be at that point in maybe another week and a half.

6mo agoHN ↗

Or even sooner if Iran intensifies striking of storages. The whole Gulf is starting to feel like a complete write off...

6mo agoHN ↗

2021 all over again except now we don’t even get a new president.

6mo agoHN ↗

Is there anyone here with a deeper understanding of oilfield geology and engineering? Given that:

- storage facilities in the region are limited and in some cases almost full

- mature oil fields need constant water injections to pump out the remaining crude

How likely is it that stopping crude extraction (and therefore the water injections) will permanently damage the oil reservoirs?

And based on that is it possible that countries with this type of mature oil fields would consider simply dumping the excess crude that can't be stored anymore in the desert or in the Gulf of Persia?

6mo agoHN ↗

There is one way that production could resume, of course: a public peace that is both real and accompanied by Iranian broadcast of orders to their coastal troops to stand down.

Given the ongoing campaign to assassinate Iranian diplomats who may be willing to negotiate peace whilst leaving hardliners alive, the only question is what kind of inducements will be necessary to get them to agree?

6mo agoHN ↗

I don't think anything short of the US completely cutting ties with Israel would make Iran consider backing down at this point. And even then, I expect they'll continue directly attacking Israel.

6mo agoHN ↗

Such a change given Iran was one of the few Middle-Eastern countries to approve of the UN resolution calling for the formation of Israel.

6mo agoHN ↗

Not exactly a recent change. Since the '79 revolution Iran has had a pretty hostile position against Israel and the US. A big part of that hostility was because the US and the UK overthrew their democracy to install a puppet dictator in '53.

6mo agoHN ↗

Indeed. Having petroleum reserves is almost always a curse. Norway seems to be the only country to have escaped unmolested.

6mo agoHN ↗

Having anything a rich person in the US wants is a curse. We've overthrown governments for bananas and sugar. We tried to overthrow a government for cigars.

Basically the only reason Norway escaped this curse was they were next door to the USSR and the US knew fucking around there could easily land it in the USSR potentially also taking Sweden with it.

6mo agoHN ↗

Everyone Iranian leader who is killed is post-facto named 'moderate', with very little proof of being moderate while alive.

6mo agoHN ↗

Is this not the heart of the problem? Israel has been killing Iranians for years. Nobody can guarantee that Israel would not break a cease fire when they feel like it.

I fear that both sides are acting completely rational: Israel wants to wipe out Iran and Iran is doing whatever they can to survive.

6mo agoHN ↗

Especially so for the consumers living in the bombed areas

6mo agoHN ↗

A few critical items beyond oil are also now in short supply:

Fertilizer, which is kind of important right now since it's springtime and farmers are planting crops around the world.

Plastic, without which modern hospitals can't operate.

Aluminum.

The list goes on, this was the dumbest war in our lifetimes but it's the culmination of a lot of previous stupidity that made it all possible.

The people who started this war are authoritarians and, let's be honest, straight up criminals, who did it to entrench their grip on their own domestic politics.

6mo agoHN ↗

the dumbest war in our lifetimes

While it is indeed foolish, it is worse than foolish, it is evil.

6mo agoHN ↗

Its a good thing. Good opportunity to push electrification of everything and ditch oil for good. I hope it keeps pushing oil prices up.

6mo agoHN ↗

Friendly reminder that every member of Trump's cabinet is a multi millionaire. This is just a game for them and there are no consequences for losing.

6mo agoHN ↗

Already feeling this even in Brazil... Right when we got inflation under control for a couple of years.

6mo agoHN ↗

You got inflation under control? Must be nice…

6mo agoHN ↗

I thought you run your favela-rovers on sugarcane gasohol?

6mo agoHN ↗

After thinking it over I'm on the side of the people of Iran. Why aren't they blowing up refineries in Corpus Christi, Texas?

6mo agoHN ↗

I’m probably missing some subtext or sarcasm here but because they don’t have ICBMs to reach the US?

6mo agoHN ↗

They could stage a "Operation Spiderweb" inspired attack [0], but this seems highly unlikely with the current powerful surveillance state of the USA. I once read a wild theory that some Mexican cartels might be able to, since they have access to military hardware too nowadays.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Spiderweb

6mo agoHN ↗

Even if they could I don't think they would. It is not in their interest. Their target selection does make sense from their point of view and it has been a restrained and capability constrained tit for tat.

For now all they seem to want is to have a financially viable future as an independent country, not as anybody's vassal, not as a country for other superpowers to play games for geopolitical reasons. Essentially to control their own destiny.

That was scuttled in 1953. Their civilian aircraft was shot down without apology. Saddam Hussein was foisted against them. They pulled through 8 years of wars that saw attacks with chemical weapons to which they lost several tens of thousands lives.

If they do not like the people who have messed with them, I cannot say that their feelings are unjustified.

I am not even Iranian.

6mo agoHN ↗

To state the obvious:

1) It is not clear that the people of Iran actually want to blow up refineries in general right now, but living in an autocracy they don't have much of a choice.

2) Because there is a pretty big ocean between them and most American civilians/infrastructure (this also enabled past colonial powers to wage war very pretty cost effectively and at their convenience). I'd like to argue that the prospect of retribution on home soil is important to stem aggressive wars, but at least for medieval Europe this apparently did not work that well either.

6mo agoHN ↗

(1) is written as if other forms of govt like a typical liberal democracy in the west or Europe give their citizens much of a choice.

6mo agoHN ↗

In a typical democracy you just vote the government out if it starts an unpopular war.

Even if elections are far away, you can just protest on the streets at basically zero risk until the government behaves again.

If you try the same in Iran you get murdered by the thousands.

6mo agoHN ↗

The buried lede: Israel did an unprovoked attack on Pars and Iran immediately retaliated by attacking QatarEnergy, which has major LNG partnerships with US oil companies.

6mo agoHN ↗

And it's important to not that until that point, both the US and Israel had not been attacking any of the Iranian production and export infrastructure, only some depots (and refineries?) for domestic use.

6mo agoHN ↗

remember your paper straws to save the planet

6mo agoHN ↗

Good. I hope gas becomes so unaffordable the US economy collapses. Maybe they'll lose some weight and it'll improve the healthcare situation.

6mo agoHN ↗

It seems highly unlikely that the US will magically have trains and more walk-able living because gas is unaffordable. Especially if it was a drastic and sudden shock of supply. Myself as much as anyone is not in favor of the reliance the US has on cars and non-renewable energy, but causing chaos is not the way to do it.

6mo agoHN ↗

i think they're saying the situation then would be such that americans won't be able to eat so much. that might shock your sensibilities, but remember that thousands of iranian civilians have been indiscriminately murdered these last couple weeks, by america.

6mo agoHN ↗

This is an interesting point. Supposing this sudden shock happens, wouldn't American towns, counties, and the like, run to buy buses and start providing emergency bus services all around to all those suburban areas where people couldn't afford gas anymore? Or at least, this is how I imagine a sane response would be.

There'd be a shortage of buses at first, but I also suppose it'd relatively easy to adapt current North American car manufacturing plants to start manufacturing buses.

But that's just an uninformed guess. Am I too much off base in this?

6mo agoHN ↗

You were right in broad strokes, but buses are too much like collective action for the taste of Americans. The most optimistic outcome I can think of is that people start buying large quantities of E bikes and pressure their towns to use all that space in their stroads to accommodate bike lanes.

6mo agoHN ↗

I went to school for industrial engineering and have worked in manufacturing the last decade or so.

Bus production would be an entire refactoring of an auto factory. Tons of equipment would need to move around, electrical conduit would need to be re-run to different places, much of the existing equipment would be too small. The equipment would need to be ordered from suppliers who already have the next couple months to years of business booked, new suppliers sourced and contracts signed, etc. On an American timeline, I can't imagine it being done in under a year if you threw money at every problem aggressively.

We did change some auto plants to manufacturing airplanes and airplane components for WWII, but there was a lot more human labor involved, manufacturing tolerances were more loose, and we had widespread support of the American public to do what we needed to make things happen. It'd be incredible to see the War Powers Act implemented to publicly fund bus transportation, but I cannot fathom that occurring with this administration.

6mo agoHN ↗

The people in the US chose chaos. Maybe we need a harsh lesson not to do that. If we are permitted to vote this November, we'll get an indication whether or not we've learned anything.

6mo agoHN ↗

Have seen social media chatter of isolated shortages in two countries already.

Hard to tell whether that’s just background noise that is just getting more airtime play thanks to Iran or whether it’s the first sign of bigger trouble.

6mo agoHN ↗

so much winning, you're gonna get sick of winning

6mo agoHN ↗

after Iran and Israel attack gasfields

After Israel attacked gasfields and Iran retaliated. Iran didn't start any of this.

6mo agoHN ↗

    Ras Laffan LNG complex in Qatar
    Ras Tanura oil refinery in Saudi
    drone attacks on Saudi oil fields
    Ruwais refinery in Abu Dhabi
    Shah gas field in Abu Dhabi
    port of Fujairah
    Bapco oil refinery in Bahrain
6mo agoHN ↗

“Oil and gas prices jump after US-proxy Israel attacks Iranian gasfield infrastructure, and after Iran responds in kind after having promised to do so.”

is a headline that reflects reality and doesn't finesse the details -- I should really become a headline writer, I'm clearly better than whoever is employed by The Guardian.

At the very least it should be "Oil and gas prices jump after Israel and then Iran attack gasfields"

Putting Iran first might lead some to believe this was Iran-initiated, which of course is probably the intention.

6mo agoHN ↗

is israel a US proxy? that's feeling a little backward right now.

6mo agoHN ↗

all proxies do this eventually.

no one ever seems to learn, you use a proxy to do dodgy shit for you and eventually they become the tail that wags the dog.

made worse in this case by the fact that trump is a weak leader and Netanyahu is not.

6mo agoHN ↗

I don't get why the prices jumped so much - looks like panic and hoarding because:

- The Middle East produces roughly 30% of the world's oil

- But about 20% of total global oil consumption flows through this strait (less than 30% because of of domestic consumption and some pipelines avoiding strait)

I would understand if prices increases e.g. 50% but like more than 100% seems like a panic or manipulation

6mo agoHN ↗

It would make sense if there was mostly inelastic demand for 80% of current production. I'm not sure if that is the case, but it might be. There is a lot of usage with no good substitute.

6mo agoHN ↗

I had this thought as well. But oil prices are set globally on the exchanges, even oil that never leaves the US is affected.

6mo agoHN ↗

Oil demand is mostly inelastic. No matter how much or how little is produced, those who need it NEED it, so they'll compete with all others who similarly need it. The richest ones from among them get the oil first, and the poorest get nothing. The end price ends up being a function of how much oil is available versus how much the richest countries' absolutely irreducibly need for oil is versus how much wealth those countries can throw at the problem not to be left without before someone else with deeper pockets gets it.

6mo agoHN ↗

Also, a third order effect of oil inelasticity is that if it cost too much , it decrease production and trade (might be less true now, but it was absolutely true in 2010), it lowers global demand, so the prices go down. Which is why markets can't predict oil prices, not really.

6mo agoHN ↗

I agree. Why is domestic oil linked to global oil price?

We are energy independent? Big Oil is milking US.

6mo agoHN ↗

if someone wants to buy American oil for twice the price overseas then it’s not gonna go to your local gas station…

6mo agoHN ↗

Surely there are some shipping expenses though? For Global Oil.

Versus the Colonial Pipeline that is prevalent on the Eastern Half of US.

6mo agoHN ↗

The ME has very low cost to produce, shipping is negligible.

6mo agoHN ↗

This is the exact reason that prices for U.S. benchmarks (e.g. WTI) are diverging from international ones (e.g. Brent). The spread between the two is the largest since 2011 and widening. There is only so much export capacity in the U.S., so there will be a glut compared to the rest of the world as a whole.

U.S. prices are up, but international prices are up even more.

6mo agoHN ↗

Uniting to fight gasfields might be just the common enemy that Iran and Israel need to finally mend this relationship.

6mo agoHN ↗

If you had a secret agenda to reduce the world's carbon production, this is one way to go about it.

6mo agoHN ↗

Except for all these burning gas and oil fields.

6mo agoHN ↗

If you break the rig on a mature oil deposit, there is a chance you will make the remaining petroleum/gas unreachable for the foreseeable future (at least at an acceptable price point). So you reduce the total oil quantity humanity will be able to extract.

6mo agoHN ↗

Time to get out our “I did that” stickers, right?

6mo agoHN ↗

I think about this every time I get gas. What was the claimed link between Biden and gas prices anyway? I feel like I missed something.

6mo agoHN ↗

Nothing more than him being president when gas prices were high.

6mo agoHN ↗

If they really are trying to provoke a revolt in Iran this was about the stupidest thing you could do. Over 800 million Iranians rely on gas for cooking and heating. Before you joke about heating in a desert. Sand radiates heat incredibly fast, nights can get below freezing in some parts of Iran.

6mo agoHN ↗

It will probably go back up to about 5 grams of Gold per barrel, which was the past peak, and hold there.

More troubling if you're paid in dollars, the end of the Petrodollar is likely now on a very accelerated timeline. Based on history, I expect a 60-80% drop in our standard of living when that happens.

6mo agoHN ↗

Stockpile (some) gasoline now because retail price shocks haven't hit yet because it takes time to ripple through the supply chain and commodity market-goods delivery price differential is in flux until supplies dry up. Supply impairments will last 1-2 years because around a dozen billion-dollar petrochem facilities have been physically destroyed and will need to be manufactured again in distant lands like Italy.