- 161comments
- 8comments
- 23comments
- 23comments
- 11comments
- 5comments
- 4comments
- 18comments
- 8comments
- 26comments
- 372comments
- —discuss
- 134comments
- 10comments
- 27comments
- 2comments
- 493comments
- 250comments
- 13comments
- 101comments
- 95comments
- 42comments
- 805comments
- 45comments
- 147comments
- 93comments
- 26comments
- 110comments
- 257comments
- 146comments
But how does it compare to floci, which already picked up with localstack left off?
you mean floci? https://floci.io/floci/
Yeah. Stupid really didn’t want to type that. :)
Floci happened to be discussed yesterday, with 47 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49854416
There are always nice, but there are a lot of scaffolding work involved with larger systems. It would be nice to be able to provide for example the terraform of the infrastructure and let these tool create their own. Might be a nice feature to add because I haven't seen it done yet.
I use tf with floci and floci-gcp, weekly…
Oh nice, not aware of this. We're opentofu on GCP, so could be a good addition to ci
I kinda like most of these emulators but why is there none targeting GCP/Azure
AWS is still way ahead in cloud usage, that's probably why AWS is the primary target. Anyway, floci has GCP and Azure versions, how mature they are, I'm unsure. But it does exist.
Right. Floci got posted yesterday here on HN.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49854416
I'm launching something in that space this week - if you're interested in trying one of those out, feel free drop me a message via my website (in bio) :)
Agreed. Azure would be nice. Something that can work with Terraform too.
Check out floci-az. I haven’t touched it but I know it’s there.
Hard to replicate all the bugs in azure.
I always welcome warmly projects like these, the only problem is that unless there’s a strong community behind, founders tend to build companies around them, raise capital, then put useful functionalities behind paywalls (see localstack).
When I see that, it always reminds me of Steve Jobs’s quote: ”It’s not a product, it’s a feature”.
Aren’t cloud companies like AWS, Azure, GCP the first to be interested in providing their users a meaningful way to do test integrations of their products? Shouldn’t they provide them in the first place?
You’d think that but it doesn’t seem to be the case. I do a lot of offline development and the only way it used to be possible was localstack but that’s AWS only. The open source community is the only interested party, it seems. Thankfully, there’s a lot of contribution happening in this space. Because I have need, I make a lot of my own contributions. I’m doing full stack cloud development against GCP without ever leaving my device.
There’s also MiniStack, which forked from LocalStack after they started breaking developer workflows: https://ministack.org/
Both fakecloud and its website look sloppily vibe-coded, and its “authors” are anonymous. It’s going to take a while for it to earn trust. I’d treat it with suspicion. (Curl-to-shell pipe to install? Ugh.)
Agreed with everything up to:
"curl-to-shell pipe to install" - what's the problem here? that's pretty common on linux systems and something the AWS CLI uses.
Or is the problem the fact that this dev is untrusted and is executing a possibly malicious script on your machine?
Running arbitrary code directly in your terminal is very dangerous
Any code I didn't write is arbitrary code. At some point I'm left to trust someone or run no software at all.
I'm worried that this behaviour has to be defended.
For a mock server? Surely a versioned, standalone executable, library/package or docker image makes more sense. Integration tests generally need to be portable and running on CI, you don't wanna be shell-piping whatever exists in the moment.
The blog posts are all attributed to "Lucas Vieira" and the dev group https://faisca.dev that is attributed as the author has 2 other projects. Lucas comes up in LinkedIn and looks like an actual person working in San Francisco.
Re: curl; this seems to work:
There are so many of these, but none of them simulate the surprise-billing experience.
File a feature request! ;)
There is also localemu, which I understand to be another localstack fork: https://localemu.cloud/