Hacker News

Top stories

Live mirror
30 storiesupdated just nowView source snapshot
  1. Android 17 is the first since 3.x to add new APIs without releasing to the AOSP(grapheneos.social ↗)
    141comments
  2. Claude Code now reads AGENTS.md if there is no Claude.md(claude.com ↗)
    42comments
  3. Saving another 100TB of RAM(cloudflare.com ↗)
    20comments
  4. Cloudflare Quick Tunnels(cloudflare.com ↗)
    205comments
  5. Xcode 27.1 Beta Release Notes(developer.apple.com ↗)
    49comments
  6. Cache-to-Cache: Direct Semantic Communication Between LLMs (2025)(arxiv.org ↗)
    10comments
  7. Photon-Emission-Guided Laser Fault Injection Enables RP2350 Secure Debug(ledger.com ↗)
    39comments
  8. Show HN: Cactus Needle 3: 8-29MB automation models can match DeepSeek V4 Flash(cactuscompute.com ↗)
    69comments
  9. How to Write with an LLM(sockpuppet.org ↗)
    221comments
  10. OpenJev(openjev.com ↗)
    234comments
  11. The Implications of Linguistic Illegibility for LLM Security(arxiv.org ↗)
    12comments
  12. C++26: Trivial infinite loops are no longer undefined behaviour(sandordargo.com ↗)
    148comments
  13. Our brain evolved from two primitive nervous systems that merged: Study(newscientist.com ↗)
    42comments
  14. The first new cat species discovered in 100 years(nationalgeographic.com ↗)
    25comments
  15. Korea raises data breach fines to 10% of revenue(koreajoongangdaily.com ↗)
    47comments
  16. I vibed a proof of Conway's conjecture(overreacted.io ↗)
    170comments
  17. How SpaceX streamlined the Raptor engine(construction-physics.com ↗)
    15comments
  18. A search-and-inference database from scratch in pure Zig(antfly.io ↗)
    12comments
  19. Minimal Phone 2(minimalcompany.com ↗)
    124comments
  20. From Geometry to Algebra and Back Again: 4000 Years of Papers (2023) [video](youtube.com ↗)
    discuss
  21. Border agents can search cellphones without a warrant or reasonable suspicion(lawandcrime.com ↗)
    104comments
  22. Cyclomatic Complexity in C#(ndepend.com ↗)
    1comments
  23. Inside ZCode: Silently uploading your Git history to the cloud(ferstar.org ↗)
    87comments
  24. Warez: The Infrastructure and Aesthetics of Piracy (2021)(archive.org ↗)
    8comments
  25. Cekura (YC F24) Is Hiring(ycombinator.com ↗)
    discuss
  26. Show HN: Ax-check.com – Can agents use your product?(ax-check.com ↗)
    24comments
  27. North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes(science.org ↗)
    143comments
  28. US Military had close call after using AI for hallucinated intelligence report(cnn.com ↗)
    243comments
  29. Mathematicians Build Long-Awaited Graph Sandwich(quantamagazine.org ↗)
    15comments
  30. Show HN: Scry, programmable internet search w/ congestion pricing(scry.io ↗)
    16comments

The Data From Comments to the FCC About Net Neutrality

25 pointsby 12y agominimaxir.com
15 comments
12y agoHN ↗

I'm confused. The article claims

    "“net neutrality,” allows internet service providers 
    (ISPs) to discriminate between different types of internet 
    traffic (a “fast lane” for video and social media, for 
    example) in an attempt to help further competition and 
    promote innovation"

and in so doing appears to conflate the FCC's new rule proposals with the abstract principle of net neutrality, which the rules would explicitly contravene.

Is some clarification possible here?

12y agoHN ↗

The first paragraph on the FCC's Open Internet brief and what you wrote are very different. You claim that net neutrality allows discrimination. The FCC's first paragraph says it doesn't.

12y agoHN ↗

As LukeB pointed out, you've reversed the meaning of the term.

I strongly recommend fixing this -- you really risk confusing the layperson and the debate.

12y agoHN ↗

It seems as though the author has mixed up pro- and anti-net neutrality (or rather, the meaning of net neutrality itself). Otherwise, the data analysis is pretty nice (though some of the maps seem to be falling to the https://xkcd.com/1138/ mistake).

12y agoHN ↗

The first one does the population mistake, which I acknowledge. (but is necessary for context)

The other maps are normalized by % of comments sent, which mitigates the population impact.

12y agoHN ↗

Wait, I submitted this yesterday and now it's on the front page of Hacker News?

The Hacker News ranking system always surprises me.

12y agoHN ↗

Identical link submissions count as votes for the original post instead. It's likely that as your post gained traction elsewhere, other users submitted the same link to HN.

12y agoHN ↗

I've been monitoring analytics and there's zero significant traffic coming from outside of HN.

12y agoHN ↗

This can't be right:

   "Looking at the data behind these comments, it’s 
   clear to see that the entire country is passionate 
   against net neutrality."

So the entire country wants "pay lanes" and "pay-per-site-access"?

12y agoHN ↗

Fixed.

This is a reminder why I should never blog while sleep deprived.

12y agoHN ↗

That means over about ¼th of the comments in the dataset, and atleast 1/10th of all comments submitted, used this website’s submission form.

Nice write up, minimaxir. I was lucky enough to be involved with Battle for the Net. We ended up successfully submitting ~135 thousand comments to the FCC.

I highly recommend people reach out to their favorite nonprofits. The projects are really fun.

12y agoHN ↗

Note: 136,398 successful sends and counting. People are still sending in comments, which rocks. Unfortunately, there were additional comments which couldn't be sent. Part of the reason being the FCC form doesn't allow military zip codes, or certain valid emails.