Hacker News

New stories

Live mirror
30 storiesupdated just nowView source snapshot
  1. The Interfaces Are Arriving(oreilly.com ↗)
    discuss
  2. Apple's Dimensional Drawings(512pixels.net ↗)
    discuss
  3. 'How can I build a bomb? It tells you how': How Boko Haram fighters are using AI(indiatimes.com ↗)
    discuss
  4. Show HN: Outbound benchmark calculators, no signup, no tracking(prospectio.ai ↗)
    discuss
  5. Everything Is a Stream: runtime composability over compile-time plugins(antigma.ai ↗)
    2comments
  6. We Tested Jev on 100 Agent Tool Calls(archestra.ai ↗)
    discuss
  7. Lazydraw: A terminal ASCII editor for drawing quick diagrams and sketches(github.com/mpospirit ↗)
    discuss
  8. The Open Newspaper(mountaineagle.net ↗)
    discuss
  9. Ask HN: What is the future status with the burning of Jev
    discuss
  10. JRR Tolkien on 'the most tragic moment' in The Lord of the Rings(bbc.com ↗)
    discuss
  11. Jev is good for agentic security use cases too(vega.io ↗)
    discuss
  12. Confectionery: A lightweight build configuration system(github.com/a5x0 ↗)
    1comments
  13. Paramount to Resolve Antitrust Lawsuit, Clearing Way for Warner Bros Acquisition(nytimes.com ↗)
    discuss
  14. SAML: A Fractal of Bad Design(trailofbits.com ↗)
    discuss
  15. Show HN: AlarmK – a mission alarm for iPhone, built on iOS 26's AlarmKit(apps.apple.com ↗)
    discuss
  16. Show HN: Jev AI –Try the Interactive Playground and Typed Decision(jev-ai.info ↗)
    discuss
  17. Thoughts on Techno-Anthropology(medium.com/kazarazat ↗)
    discuss
  18. Running an Optimal Trace(anishathalye.com ↗)
    discuss
  19. Show HN: FractalBrainOS – self-learning brain in C++17 (no backprop)(github.com/nineni999nenine ↗)
    discuss
  20. White House press pool (5 networks) suspends coverage(nytimes.com ↗)
    1comments
  21. Show HN: Mathy – Build Math Automaticity(mathy.game ↗)
    discuss
  22. Skill and visualisation kit to help developers understand PRs better(github.com/annanay25 ↗)
    1comments
  23. OpenClaw Completes Security Audit(openclaw.ai ↗)
    discuss
  24. U.S. Site Blocking Bill Adds VPNs to the List of Blocking Intermediaries(torrentfreak.com ↗)
    discuss
  25. Show HN: HN for Me – Jev curates Hacker News based on your interests(github.com/raahelpie ↗)
    discuss
  26. Practical model evaluation and compression tools(github.com/0xsero ↗)
    discuss
  27. FUSE over Io_uring(camandro.org ↗)
    discuss
  28. Aikido Altar: open-weight security model(aikido.dev ↗)
    2comments
  29. A study of sequence weighting at scale(janestreet.com ↗)
    discuss
  30. The Biopolitics of Intelligence(muskdeer.blogspot.com ↗)
    discuss

M5 Ultra Mac Studio Review: The Dream Mac for Local AI Agents

58 pointsby 1h agomacstories.net
23 comments
52m agoHN ↗

The numbers I was most interested in are tucked away in a chart towards the bottom - the speed comparison of the Mac Studios v.s. a RTX 5090:

  Qwen3.8 27B tokens/sec generation speed

  Prompt size    8K    64K   128K   256K
  RTX 5090 PC    59    51    44     n/a
  M5 Ultra       48    39    32     24
  M3 Ultra       31    23.5  20     15

A whole bunch more comparison numbers in this section: https://www.macstories.net/stories/m5-ultra-mac-studio-revie...

19m agoHN ↗

Those are some incredible graphs, that leap in prompt processing going from M3 to M5.

Also: ~30 token/s on GLM 5.3-flash, locally.

/meta Here's a CSS filter that stops those nuisance chart animations,

    macstories.net##*:style(animation: none !important; transition: none !important)
18m agoHN ↗

A dense 27B doesn't really make sense for the Mac. A MoE makes way more sense when you have modest bandwidth but lots of memory.

11m agoHN ↗

They do MoE. They benchmarked GLM 5.3-flash (320B / 18B), and Qwen 3.8-flash-next (125B / 6B). The dense Qwen is only focused (I assume) because it's about the only thing that fits on a 5090, that they can compare the two heads on.

16m agoHN ↗

Those RTX 5090 numbers are bad. You can get over 200 tps with ninfer using NVFP4 and MTP.

16m agoHN ↗

Thank you for this. I wish Apple focused their silicon design on improving the TTFT metrics but coming from an M3 Pro, it still looks laggard compared to Nvidia's TensorCores in the 5090.

Maybe Apple is an acquisition away from changing that balance.

47m agoHN ↗

On Apple website it says 512GB memory option is available in October. I guess bumping to that one would cost additional 4-6k US$. So an Ultra with 2TB storage would be north of 15k US$.

That’s like 12 years worth of OpenAI Pro subscriptions

39m agoHN ↗

Agreed.

Specially since one can pay half right now to OpenAI and sign a 12 year iron clad contract for uninterrupted service delivery of OpenAI Pro.

11m agoHN ↗

I think we all expect the heavy subsidized subscriptions to end or significantly increase in price at some point, but it could be years from now and I'd rather spend a similar figure on an hypotetical Mac Studio M8 Ultra, or whatever more advanced competitor that will have likley appeared by that time.

A more apples-to-apples comparison would be with API cost in OpenRouter at the same tok/s rate for the same models that you can run locally, maybe.

35m agoHN ↗

Yeah, anyone who thinks local AI is going to save them money is likely to be disappointed, at least if they want to run models that are even remotely capable.

Plenty of other reasons to get excited about it local AI, but I don't think cost is one of them.

10m agoHN ↗

Maybe you are using a local model to go after some Millennium Prize problem and you don't want OpenAI to take your work and use it to win the prize for themselves? $15k might be a bargain.

And, yes, I know a current local model wasn't going to solve the Navier-Stokes problem, but I'm just using it as an example where privacy might be valuable.

29m agoHN ↗

Hard to guess, it can go either way. If you will need to be in a syndicate to use non-sterilized models, that mac makes sense. But if there is mandatory registration of personal cyberarms, you risk going to mines once they check you purchases. You could try to play normie and pretend you simply wanted to show off, by keeping your actual work on external disk, but that leaves traces on system. Counting on someone in the Gap renting you gray iron works as long as you can swap credits. Still, this gear is tiny. Put it in your e-car, with uplink, and leave it at uncle's farm. Discreet.

41m agoHN ↗

The model being tested is 18k as configured.

I didn't expect this to make the 5090 to look like a good deal.

40m agoHN ↗

"It also happens to be a Mac, with an operating system that looks nice and doesn’t suck"

Yes Apple has some of the best hardware out there, albeit overpriced. But the software is such a hindrance and I can't take anyone that states otherwise seriously. If only it had proper Linux support (and the Asahi people do an amazing job but you can reverse-engineer only so many stuff with limited funding, and then you have to do it again for new models). MacOS is good if you just want to have a standard experience, which to be fair is most people. It's good for just setting up an LLM server I guess since the hardware is a perfect fit. I wouldn't touch it otherwise.

36m agoHN ↗

This is great as a first look, but the author is not a developer, so we don't yet know whether a dev can be as productive with local models on M5 Mac Studio compared to a 20x subscription plan.

I'm also curious about any new low hanging optimization opportunities in the kernels for this new hardware.

It's already clear to me that M5 Mac Studio is more cost-effective than anything you can run on open router, assuming decent utilization.

The M5 Mac Studio will be the most cost effective way to run uncensored cyber capable open agents.

An exciting tipping point will be if programmers can get an Astra-Ultra like experience all week with this hardware. That would be a real sense where this hardware exceeds the value of even 20x cloud subscriptions.

35m agoHN ↗

Let’s address the elephant in the room first: why bother with local AI at all when cloud frontier models are better and often faster?

Ehh, the actual elephant in the room is:

"why bother with local AI at all when you can lease a GPU for $5/hr?"

To which the answer is you shouldn't bother, unless you have a bunch of money to throw at hobby projects.

31m agoHN ↗

While I know it's not apples to apples, the target comparison right now is 2x DGX Sparks. Similar price, 256gb. The conversation has focused on memory bandwidth vs. compute in agentic loops, so for most people the raw numbers will mean less than the "time per task" in coding benchmarks.

This is a great article and bodes well for the M5, but we should expect more like this comparing to other platforms before we truly understand where it fits.

15m agoHN ↗

Imagine spending a trillion dollars on data centers and then reading this article. Nightmare fuel for OpenAI

10m agoHN ↗

For 99.99% of people, spending 15 grand on a Mac Studio just to run Qwen 3.8 locally is a non starter.